Close

Member Login

Invalid username or password.
Incorrect Login. Please try again.

not a member? sign-up now!

Whether or Not to Tell the Truth about Third Party Reproduction

|
Jan 23, 2009
image-tell-the-truth

Telling Your Child

When it comes to sharing with your child the story of how he or she came to be born, there’s more that we know about the best ways to do this, and why it’s important to share this information with your son or daughter. That’s because a lot of research has looked at this question with adoptees. Those studies have found that keeping this secret from your child can have damaging effects on the whole family, and that children often sense something is wrong or missing. If part of your hesitation in sharing your child’s beginning with her is tied to your own grief at not being able to start your family in the conventional way, that’s natural. But it’s important that you examine that loss and pain and not ignore it. Doing so should make it easier to share more openly how your child came into the world and help you reconnect with the joyful parts of that process.

Once you’re ready to talk to your child, don’t be surprised if it feels strange. But it really does get easier once you start the conversation! Experts agree that the simple telling and retelling of your child’s story from as early as preschool age is a wonderful way for her to grow up with accurate information about her conception. If you could use a little help in what to say to a young child, try these two children’s books, both recommended by the American Society of Reproductive Medicine: Butterflies and Magical Wings by Amy Margolis (Thompson Press, 2006) and Mommy, Was Your Tummy Big? A Picture Book That Explains Donor Eggs to Children by Carolina Nadel (Mookind Press, 2007).

If you choose to wait until your child is a bit older, be aware that if others know about the origins of his birth, there is a chance that he could find out accidentally—and maybe not in the way you would like. Waiting until adolescence is not advisable; these are the years when a young person is coming to grips with his identity, and hearing this life-changing information for the first time during his teenage years is likely to be particularly challenging.




A version of this story originally appeared in the Fall 2007 issue of Conceive Magazine.

Related Topics: Assisted Reproduction; Egg Donation; Sperm Donation; Surrogacy

Article Pager

Reader Faves

  • image-impatientwoman
    If so, Dr. Jean Twenge's brand-new book is for you. Dr. Twenge has written "The Impatient Woman's Guide to Getting Pregnant," and shares some of her best advice in the first of our two-part interview with her. (Check back on April 23 for part two!)
  • image-saveonfertilitymeds
    The cost of fertility medications can force many couples to question whether they can continue infertility treatment. But there are ways to save, and...
  • image-miscarriage-the-feelings
    A noted poet, professor, and essay writer describes the loss of her first pregnancy. Now, years later, this mother of two happy, healthy children...
  • image-randine
    As author of The Infertility Cure and  The Way of the Fertile Soul, Randine Lewis, Ph.D., L.Ac., has been a pioneer in introducing eastern medicine to western couples to help them become parents.