Close

Member Login

Invalid username or password.
Incorrect Login. Please try again.

not a member? sign-up now!

Older celebrity moms: Encouraging or annoying?

More celebrities in their 40s and even older are giving birth, and it's a fair guess that many are using donor eggs to do so. Do they owe the public an explanation when they used egg donation -- or is it their own business, even if they're misleading people into thinking it's easy to get pregnant in your 40s and 50s? We want to hear your opinion.
|
Jan 18, 2012
Conceive Online
Photo by: Splash News

It’s no secret that in recent years more celebrities in their 40s -- some even in their 50s -- are giving birth. But what’s often not clear is whether they used their own eggs to have a child. Most of these women choose not to comment on the matter – as is their right; at the end of the day, it is no one’s business how their child was conceived, right? – so if they did use donor eggs to get pregnant, the public doesn't know and by saying nothing many of us might believe a woman in her 40s or 50s delivered her own biological child. And a few do.

In some ways it’s a natural deduction. We’ve been led to believe that the miracles of fertility treatments like in vitro fertilization (IVF) and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) can solve nearly any conception difficulty a woman or couple might come across. But those of us who haven’t been able to conceive, or deliver a healthy baby, know better. It ain’t that easy, and medicine doesn’t have an answer for everyone. Even when there are "answers," they are often hard-won, and years in the making.

So on the one hand it may be heartening to see older women getting pregnant and having a family, or adding to their family later, on their own terms, when they’re ready – it may seem they're living the dream of "having it all" - a carefree youth, time and energy for career advancement, and then the joys of motherhood, when there is probably more time, money, and perspective to enjoy it all.

On the other hand, though, it’s worth mentioning that, in all likelihood, many of these women did not conceive easily, and a fair number probably didn’t conceive and carry a child that is biologically theirs – even if their silence implies they did. The potential danger in this is not to women and couples who are already dealing with difficulty conceiving (we know how they likely got pregnant, and are probably very sympathetic to anyone who struggles as we have), but there may be a real risk in implying to younger women that you can have it all – wait until your late 30s, your 40s, even your 50s and still have the family you want. Or even implying that high fertility is universal, that all women have pretty much the same “amounts” of it, which is simply not true.

ConceiveOnline.com wants to hear what you think: Do you think it’s entirely a woman’s business (and no one else’s) how she conceived? Or does a woman over 35, 40, or 50 owe it to others to be upfront if she had to use an egg donor to have a baby? What are the child’s rights in this situation? What would you do - or have you done?

 

Article Pager

Reader Faves

  • image-impatientwoman
    If so, Dr. Jean Twenge's brand-new book is for you. Dr. Twenge has written "The Impatient Woman's Guide to Getting Pregnant," and shares some of her best advice in the first of our two-part interview with her. (Check back on April 23 for part two!)
  • image-saveonfertilitymeds
    The cost of fertility medications can force many couples to question whether they can continue infertility treatment. But there are ways to save, and...
  • image-miscarriage-the-feelings
    A noted poet, professor, and essay writer describes the loss of her first pregnancy. Now, years later, this mother of two happy, healthy children...
  • image-randine
    As author of The Infertility Cure and  The Way of the Fertile Soul, Randine Lewis, Ph.D., L.Ac., has been a pioneer in introducing eastern medicine to western couples to help them become parents.